注册 登录  
 加关注
   显示下一条  |  关闭
温馨提示!由于新浪微博认证机制调整,您的新浪微博帐号绑定已过期,请重新绑定!立即重新绑定新浪微博》  |  关闭

信奉市场

In Freedom We Believe 奥地利学派

 
 
 

日志

 
 
关于我

铅笔经济研究社理事。现居北京,供职于某报社。一个自由市场经济的拥护者。坚定地信奉自由市场经济理念,推崇自由贸易,不遗余力地反对政府对市场的干预和调控。坚信繁荣和幸福来自于自由选择,来自于每个人自己对自己负责任。

网易考拉推荐

真主啊,你为什么要把他们扔到火里呢?  

2006-01-09 22:16:41|  分类: 政治学随笔 |  标签: |举报 |字号 订阅

  下载LOFTER 我的照片书  |

       真主啊,你为什么要把他们扔到火里呢?
                            
——一个前***的疑问




加西亚按:
党章规定,共产党员可以自愿退党。 那么***可以因觉悟而抛弃伊斯兰教,改而信奉自己选择的其他宗教信仰吗?

据我所知,在奉行伊斯兰Sharia法律的国家,脱离伊斯兰那可是死罪!即使温和的马来西亚,据说还得被逮捕,强行接受‘悔改教育课程’,重新认识自己的‘思想过错’。就算内心不肯就范,身份证上的宗教信仰一栏,永远只能是初始登记的***身份,严厉禁止更改。

下面是一则孟加拉人(曾是***)的自白,坦诚他为何认为伊斯兰是荒谬的。很值得一读。







     真主啊,你为什么要把他们扔到火里呢? 

           作者:伊姆兰.侯赛因。     翻译:(万科大雪冷饮)加西亚


有兴趣可以与他交流,邮箱是:
ImranHossainBD@hotmail.com

2005/10/11

有时我会疑惑我为什么对我的一些最亲近的亲戚和朋友真心信仰的东西没有感觉。我有自己的价值观。我总是希望享受个人自由,希望看到人人平等,希望为这个世界变得更好而做些事情。然而,孩提时代所受的伊斯兰教育总是试图将这些理念挤出我的头脑。在我的思想和伊斯兰教义之间我不知道如何做出选择。

得承认我必须感谢我的父亲,他从没有告诉我去实践伊斯兰教义,一次都没有。而我的姐姐则在我的头脑中播下了对****的怀疑以及对《古兰经》的荒谬性的认识的种子。今天,我将分享我对伊斯兰教的观点,正是这些观点使我成为了一名自由思想者。

在我十岁的时候,家人为我请了一胡贾尔(讲授伊斯兰教义的老师)。为了让我阅读《古兰经》,他教我阿拉伯语。他教我如何祷告,如何奉行斋戒。我祷告了,也斋戒了,但我没有感受到任何东西。他们都在装模作样地举行那些仪式。我的胡贾尔(老师)每次来都要对我进行博言(阿语“作报告、劝诫”),让我相信真主阿拉和默罕默德。他告诉我如何站在乌玛(***兄弟)一边,不要和非***作朋友,尤其是犹太人。

我的胡贾尔(老师)说只有***才有资格上天堂,而***都是真主的敌人。我们应该为伊斯兰而战斗到底。 不止是老师,其它***也是这么对我说的。尽管这种观念很明显是在播种仇恨的种子,但他们总是在告诉我“伊斯兰教是和平的宗教”。

许多年后,很多问题不断在敲打我的脑袋。最基本的问题是:为什么如果我生在一个非***家庭我就注定是仇恨的对象呢?那些无辜的非***犯了什么错,为什么真主要把他们扔到永恒的地狱之火里面去呢?为什么真主要在他们(非***)和我们(***)之间垒起一座高墙呢?既然我们如此厌恶非***,为什么还要说伊斯兰教是一个和平的宗教呢?

我曾经以为我误解了伊斯兰教的教义和事实。我曾经想我应该去了解真正的伊斯兰教,以消除我的这些错误观念。我拜访了很多伊斯兰学者,向他们提出我的问题,但我得到的是一些稀奇古怪的答案。

大多数***都是好人。然而我不得不承认,当他们要“保卫”伊斯兰教的时候,他们的观点往往就表现得极其白痴,很多人还想消灭犹太人、非***和其他的宗教信仰者。这些***平时都非常友好,但一涉及到对伊斯兰教义的争论就变得极其嗜血。

我希望谈到非***的时候能够不偏不倚,但我听到的那些***谈到关于非***的时候从来都是纠缠不清、毫无公正可言。他们经常告诉我,在各方面都要给***以优先权。这显然非常不公平。

事实上,我们要了解一棵树,我们可以通过它结的果子。***是伊斯兰教结的果子。因此,伊斯兰就是***。伊斯兰和***互相依存。如果我们不能期望***有什么好行为,那么谁能传承伊斯兰教义的那些“美德”呢?这就是我对伊斯兰教失望的原因。

我也试图在伊斯兰教义里面找到广而告之的“和平”。我们都知道根据伊斯兰教义,批评伊斯兰教的人和放弃伊斯兰信仰的人(阿语:穆尔塔德)将被处死;不能和非***作朋友或兄弟;通奸者将被用石头砸死;饮酒者和其他做了错事的人将受到鞭刑;小偷将被砍掉双手,等等等等。这些怎么能够代表和平呢?死刑、战争、鞭刑、石头砸死罪犯、以及仇恨怎么能够成为和平的符号呢?当伊斯兰教杀死批评伊斯兰教和退出伊斯兰教的人的时候,我们怎么能说它是一个和平的宗教呢?在这些伊斯兰教义中,我无法找到公正。

同时我也在质疑为什么孟加拉国的人民应该去崇拜和信仰阿拉伯的帝国主义。这会让我们的道路走得更好么?我们接受了他们的(阿拉伯的)文化和宗教,但是我们并没有受到他们的公平对待。我们为什么要追随他们的价值观?我们有我们自己的文化和宗教。

伊斯兰教义说非***都应该下地狱,对此我无法认同。难道如特丽莎修女那样的博爱的人道主义者也应该下地狱被烧死吗?难道像萨达姆那样的独裁暴君也应该上天堂,仅仅因为他信伊斯兰教?难道真主仅仅因为一个人出生在非***家庭而送他下地狱?这种教义显然充满了歧视。

我旅居的国家(美国)给予了我巨大的帮助。签证官给了我们签证。这个国家的政府让我们享受到平等的权利。为了治疗我的父亲和亲戚,这个国家的卫生部门花掉了数十万美元。这个国家无条件的帮助贫穷的国家。问题是:为什么这个国家的那些慷慨大方、古道热肠的人民应该下地狱,永远受地狱之火的煎熬?我根本无法接受伊斯兰教的这个教义。

而正是这些富有创新精神的异教徒(阿语:卡费勒)让***们比以前更加容易实践伊斯兰教义。睁开眼睛,你所看到的所有有用的东西都是这些异教徒发明的。而***在每天五次的祷告和每年一次的斋月(阿语:莱麦丹)中浪费着时间。***乘坐着飞机和其他的高速交通工具到麦加朝圣。他们在集市上用计算器计算交易的数额。五分之四的伊斯兰纪念柱都由非***的产品制作而成。不幸的是这些帮助了***的人都将被安排到地狱居住。我不能认同对这些富有创造力、让这世界变得更美好的异教徒的下地狱永远受地狱之火焚烧的审判。

我对伊斯兰教的怀疑随着年岁的增长而一天天增加,更多的疑问,但从未找到满意的答案。我也在试图找到和我有同样想法的人。大约两年半以前,我找到了一个由孟加拉裔开的网站www.vinnomot.com 。读到这个网站的文章我感到很惊讶。尽管这些文章对我来说是新的,但我感觉到我期待这些文章很长时间了。我意识到我并不孤单,很多人像我一样对伊斯兰教有着同样的疑惑。

尽管如此,我仍在想网站上的这些世俗的人会不会被误导、会不会对伊斯兰教有错误的解读呢?于是,我又开始阅读《古兰经》和《哈迪斯》,以了解伊斯兰教的真相。后来,我终于知道,这个网站上的作者是对的,***宣传家们没有掌握真理,我对伊斯兰教的质疑被证实了。

这世上没有所谓的唯一真神唯一真教唯一真言,而只有极度愚蠢糊涂受思想控制的奴隶,活死人。



原文:(有兴趣的可以对照阅读)


Why do you put them into fire,Allah?


By Imran Hossain



Sometimes I wonder why I am not near what my most relatives and friends believe in by heart. I have my own values. I always want to enjoy my personal freedom, see all people equal, and do something better for this wide world. However, Islamic teachings in childhood strived to squeeze my mind. I was confused to make a choice between my thoughts and Islam.

In acknowledgement I must thank my father who never said to me to practise Islam, not even once, and my elder sister who first sow the seed of doubt in my mind about Muhammad and the absurdity in Quran. Today I will present my views on Islam that led me to become a freethinker.

A hujur (Islamic teacher) was hired for me when I was about ten. He used to teach Arabic so that I can read the Quran. He taught me how to perform the prayers and observer the fast. I prayed and fasted but did not feel anything. They were just fake rituals. My hujur used to give a boyan (lecture) after every visit and he made me believe in Allah and Muhammad. He taught me how to stand by the Ummah (Muslim brotherhood) and not to be friends of non-Muslims, especially the Jews.

My hujur said only Muslims deserve to go to heaven and non-Muslims are enemies of Allah. We therefore need to fight for Islam until the end. This is what I learned also from other Muslims. Despite this sowing the seeds of hatred, I was constantly told that “Islam is a religion of peace.”

After a few years, many questions were knocking on my head. My primary questions were:

Why would I be a subject of hate if I were born to a non-Muslim family?
What is wrong with innocent non-Muslims and why would Allah put them to hellfire for eternity?
Why would Allah create a wall between them and us?
If we dislike so much the non-Muslims, then why do we say Islam is a religion of peace?


I thought I must have been mistaken to know the fact of Islam. I realised that I must know the real Islam to get rid of such misconception. I went to many Islamic scholars to ask my questions and found strange answers.

The majority of Muslims are good people. However, I must admit the truth that most of them talk brainlessly and some of them want to eliminate Jews or non-Muslims and other religions only when they go defending Islam. These Muslims are very nice, but they become bloodthirsty for Islam while arguing.



I wanted to be unbiased about non-Muslims but the comments that I heard about them were often fuzzy and not without a prejudice. I was always told to give preference to Muslims. This sounded very unfair.

As a matter of fact, we can know the tree by its fruits. A Muslim is the fruit of Islam. Therefore, Islam means Muslims. Islam and Muslims depend on each other. If we cannot expect good things from Muslims, then who can present the goodies of Islam? This is what made me very disappointed of Islam.

I tried to find the advertised “peace” in Islam. We all know that critics and apostates (Murtads) of Islam are killed. Non-Muslims must not be friends or brothers. The adulterer must be stoned to death. Drinkers and other wrongdoers are flogged. Thieves lose their hands, and many more. How can all these represent peace? Can killing, fighting, flogging, stoning, and hating be a symbol of peace? How can I say Islam is a religion of peace when it kills its critics and apostates? I cannot find justification in this teaching.

I was trying to see why Bangladeshi people needed to worship the Arab imperialism. Does it make us lead better? We adopt their (Arabs’) culture and religion, but we are not treated well by them. What is the actual point to follow their values? We had our own culture and religion.

Islam says all non-Muslims will go to hell. I could not agree with this. Would humanitarians like Mother Theresa burn for eternity, but tyrants like Saddam go to heaven eventually just because they are believers? Would God send people to hell just because he made them born in non-Muslim families? This seemed to be too much discrimination.

People of my host country have been a greater help to me. The visa officers issued visas for us. The authority of my host country lets us enjoy equal rights. The health ministry spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on treatment of my father and relatives. The government of the country unconditionally help poor countries. The question is - why will the generous people of my host country burn in hell for eternity? I cannot accept this value of Islam at all.

It is true that the innovative infidels (Kafirs) are making Muslims much easier to practise Islam than ever. All the useful stuffs that you see in your open eyes are invented by the infidels. Muslims waste time for their five-time per day prayers and Ramadan. Muslims use aeroplanes and speedy vehicles to go to Mecca for hajj. They use calculators to make payments for Zakat. Four of the five pillars of Islam are performed with the help of non-Muslim products. Unfortunately, the helpers of Muslims will be residents of hell. I could not agree with the judgement that the creative infidels who made the world better will burn in hell for eternity.

My suspicion in Islam grew more day-by-day and many questions came to me but found no good answers. I tried to look for people who think like me. About two and half years ago, I found a website www.vinnomot.com operated by someone form Bangladeshi origin. I was surprised to read the posts on the site. Although the articles were new to me, I imagined that I was expecting the same for a long time. I realized I am not alone I my thinking, but many others have the same doubt about Islam as I do.

Despite that, I thought what if all these secular people on the site are misguided and misinterpreting Islam? Therefore, I started reading the Quran and Hadith to know the truth about Islam. Later on, I came to know that the authors on the site were correct, Muslim propagandists were not presenting the truth, and my suspicion about Islam was confirmed.

  评论这张
 
阅读(400)| 评论(3)
推荐 转载

历史上的今天

在LOFTER的更多文章

评论

<#--最新日志,群博日志--> <#--推荐日志--> <#--引用记录--> <#--博主推荐--> <#--随机阅读--> <#--首页推荐--> <#--历史上的今天--> <#--被推荐日志--> <#--上一篇,下一篇--> <#-- 热度 --> <#-- 网易新闻广告 --> <#--右边模块结构--> <#--评论模块结构--> <#--引用模块结构--> <#--博主发起的投票-->
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

页脚

网易公司版权所有 ©1997-2017